Shutterstock
You may need seen media articles or health influencers on-line urging individuals to do “useless hangs”, the place one hangs loosely from a bar – normally with toes off the ground. The objective is normally to enhance upper-body energy and shoulder stability, or stretch out muscle tissues across the shoulder.
But what does the science say? Are useless hangs good for shoulder well being?
As with so many issues well being and health, it’s not a simple “sure” or “no”. It actually relies on your motive for doing it, your particular person biology, and the way you do them. For some, useless hangs might danger musculoskeletal damage.
For some, useless hangs might danger musculoskeletal damage.
Shutterstock
The shoulder: a comparatively unstable joint
Dead hangs might enhance grip energy and endurance in rock climbers. This means that in the event you’re effectively tailored to this sort of train and have superb upper-body energy, useless hangs might deliver hand and forearm advantages.
But whereas useless hangs could also be OK for individuals with good upper-body energy and no shoulder issues, they are often dangerous for others. People with shoulder hypermobility (extreme movement of the shoulder) or shoulder instability (comparable to those that simply dislocate their shoulder) might must be cautious.
The shoulder, by design, is a comparatively unstable joint. It has a big ball-type bone referred to as a humerus, which sits in a comparatively small socket referred to as a glenoid.
The passive (non-muscle) tissue round these bones (the capsule, labrum and ligaments) creates a beneficiant area across the shoulder joint – all so you may transfer your arm although a wide variety of movement.
Because there’s not a lot passive help within the shoulder, it depends closely on energetic muscle coordination and energy to maintain it secure.
The coordination of muscle tissues across the shoulder blade assist preserve the socket in the best place, and the rotator cuff and deltoid muscle tissues assist to regulate the “ball” within the centre of the socket as you progress.
All this implies useless hangs, if not accomplished appropriately, may current a danger for individuals with hypermobility of their shoulders.
The shoulder, by design, is a comparatively unstable joint.
Shutterstock
Hypermobility and the shoulder
Some individuals have extreme movement of their joints as a result of elevated elasticity of joint tissue. This is known as hypermobility and could also be within the shoulder or all joints.
The overhead arm place of a whole useless cling places you ready the place, inside your shoulder, the ball is pulled away from the socket. Hanging your whole physique weight can, in hypermobile individuals, trigger the tissue to stretch much more.
People with shoulder hypermobility usually tend to develop painful shoulder instability, which is when the ball typically pops out of the socket.
Shoulder instability could also be attributable to acute trauma (comparable to dislocation). Or it could possibly develop over time from a lack of muscle management, deriving from micro-trauma (by, for instance, swimming laps within the pool with hand paddles).
Shoulder instability is related to diminished energy and coordination within the shoulder muscle tissues. In individuals underneath 40, it’s typically misdiagnosed as “rotator cuff ache” or “shoulder muscle tightness”.
Some persons are extra versatile than others within the shoulder.
Shutterstock
What can I do as a substitute of useless hangs?
Dead hangs require good baseline energy, can danger popping the ball from the socket for some individuals, and might stretch the passive tissue. They will not be one of the best train for these for shoulder hypermobility and instability.
So what’s the choice? A therapy referred to as the Watson Instability Program has had good outcomes for resolving non-traumatic shoulder instability when in comparison with a normal shoulder energy program.
This program focuses on gaining shoulder blade management (such because the upward rotation you get once you attain as much as a excessive shelf). It entails recruiting the shoulder blade and shoulder joint muscle tissues to enhance the contact between the ball and the socket.
Building shoulder blade management and energy will help increase broader shoulder energy.
Still eager to strive useless hangs?
If you might be decided to do useless hangs, keep in mind to:
begin with small increments; cling for simply ten seconds or fewer at first, and construct from there
don’t enable your self to get too fatigued; your shoulder joint can turn into much less secure when it’s drained
strive stepping off a field underneath the bar quite than leaping as much as the bar
preserve some “energetic” tone in your shoulders as you cling; hanging fully passively can include danger.
Try to maintain some energetic tone in your muscle tissues as you cling.
Shutterstock
Our staff is conducting a trial of the Watson Instability Program. We are investigating mind modifications in sufferers with multidirectional instability of the shoulder.
If you’re feminine, aged 18-35, have non-traumatic, right-sided shoulder instability and wish to have the prospect to obtain six months of free Watson Instability Program physiotherapy therapy as a part of our examine, please contact both of us or learn extra in regards to the examine right here.
Charlotte Ganderton receives funding from Arthritis Australia, Physiotherapy Research Foundation, Swinburne University of Technology, National Institute of Circus Arts and La Trobe University. Charlotte Ganderton is a member of the Australian Physiotherapy Association and Sports Medicine Australia.
Sarah Warby consults and receives analysis funds from the Melbourne Shoulder Group.
