NFstock/Shutterstock
Spain not too long ago adopted a menstrual depart coverage, which makes extra (paid or unpaid) days off work out there to “solely and all cisgender girls”.
It’s so nice that we’re having extra public conversations about menstrual and menopausal well being, however I’m getting very bored with being informed that menstrual depart is the answer.
As somebody with a background in coverage analysis and the founding father of the world’s first evidence-based menstrual well being web site, I’m properly positioned to touch upon this subject. When I evaluated present menstrual depart insurance policies world wide, I discovered that they weren’t progressive or helpful for feminine reproductive well being or gender equality.
The factor is, it’s actually exhausting to argue towards one thing that sounds good, even when the out there proof suggests in any other case. Humans appear to be dangerous at going past floor ideas and we could even choose tales that align with moderately than problem gender stereotypes.
So, here’s a fast define of what I feel you need to learn about this coverage.
What is the issue?
There are 4 predominant arguments utilized by these selling menstrual depart coverage:
It will make the office match for the menstruating feminine physique.
It will enhance menstrual well being.
It will scale back menstrual disgrace and stigma, and related discrimination.
It will enhance gender equality within the office and past.
However, it has by no means been made clear precisely how the coverage will ship these outcomes. In truth, primarily based on what we learn about present menstrual depart insurance policies, it won’t contribute to any of them.
This article is a part of Quarter Life, a collection about points affecting these of us in our twenties and thirties. From the challenges of starting a profession and taking good care of our psychological well being, to the thrill of beginning a household, adopting a pet or simply making associates as an grownup. The articles on this collection discover the questions and produce solutions as we navigate this turbulent interval of life._
You could also be focused on:
Five necessary issues you need to have realized in intercourse ed – however in all probability didn’t
Postpartum train can have many advantages – right here’s how you can do it safely
Joy may help us be higher at work – right here’s how you can discover it
For occasion, the coverage doesn’t make it simpler to handle your interval at work as a result of your employer doesn’t have to alter a factor. Instead, you’re inspired to keep away from the office.
The coverage additionally does nothing to enhance menstrual well being. The 90% of people that menstruate and don’t often expertise extreme signs don’t have to take a complete break day work throughout their intervals.
Meanwhile, the minority who do often expertise extreme signs nearly all the time have an underlying well being concern, equivalent to endometriosis, heavy menstrual bleeding, polycystic ovary syndrome, fibroids, auto-immune problems, melancholy or premenstrual dysphoric dysfunction. Encouraging individuals to deal with extreme signs alone at dwelling each month, will not be an efficient or humane answer.
These well being circumstances deserve efficient and well timed medical prognosis and remedy, sick depart and cheap office changes. The similar issues that apply to all power well being circumstances and are already lined by EU and UK labour insurance policies.
Menstrual depart additionally doesn’t assist to scale back menstrual disgrace, stigma or discrimination. It really encourages the elimination of menstruation – and by extension girls – from the general public realm by hiding it at dwelling.
This sex-based coverage conflates wholesome intervals with debilitating menstrual well being circumstances, which each pathologises the conventional feminine physique and undermines well being circumstances that primarily have an effect on girls. This is partly why girls and circumstances that primarily have an effect on girls usually tend to be dismissed by medical doctors, generally taking years to get a proper prognosis.
Finally, by medicalising the menstrual cycle (that’s, positioning it as an sickness moderately than a wholesome course of) these insurance policies reinforce sexist beliefs that make it seem to be all girls are biologically inferior (mentally and bodily). This is a serious contributing consider gender discrimination, particularly within the office, since these concepts are used to undermine the worth, contribution and management potential of ladies.
Period depart insurance policies maintain menstruation at dwelling the place employers don’t must cope with it.
Fizkes/Shutterstock
Menstrual depart would possibly even make issues worse
Not solely have present menstrual depart insurance policies failed to deal with the issues they got down to resolve, they’ve additionally immediately resulted in discrimination towards feminine employees. This is essentially because of the gender myths bolstered by the coverage. It makes all girls seem to be dearer and fewer constant and productive workers. It may result in a backlash from colleagues and employers towards a sex-based profit.
We already know that shared parental depart (for fogeys no matter gender) is a simpler coverage than maternity depart (which is feminine sex-based). It improves the gender pay hole, girls’s hiring, promotion and management alternatives, youngster well being outcomes, fatherhood experiences and gender equality in wider society.
These enhancements happen as a result of the coverage avoids the gender-based backlash related to maternity depart. This backlash is pushed by the aware or unconscious resentment of, and related discrimination towards, working girls on account of a perceived unfair benefit (paid day off work) and/or organic legal responsibility (the feminine reproductive physique). The similar points apply to menstrual and menopausal well being office insurance policies.
We want to enhance office (and faculty, and medical) data of reproductive well being and wellbeing. We ought to all know what’s regular or the signal of an underlying well being situation. Likewise, it’s stunning that some individuals have no idea why we menstruate or how you can scale back cyclical modifications.
We additionally have to make workplaces (together with colleges) match for individuals who have intervals and to advertise extra versatile and equitable work cultures and practices that profit all workers. For occasion, difficult “presenteeism” if workers really feel obliged to work even when feeling unwell, and ditching “timed” rest room breaks.
While these actions are usually not fairly as easy or catchy as “menstrual depart”, they’d at the least make a constructive distinction within the lives of thousands and thousands of employees – with out unintentionally worsening gender inequalities.
Sally King is the founding father of Menstrual Matters. Her doctoral analysis was funded by the ESRC (Economic and Social Research Council). She is affiliated with the Women's Equality Party and a board member of the Society for Menstrual Cycle Research.
